I live in an area of the country surrounded by Amish farms as well as a smaller Mennonite population.

For about the past year, each time I stop at the farm about four miles down the road to purchase eggs, baked goods or maple syrup; the Amish lady that usually answers the door is surprisingly quite friendly.  Always has a little conversation and a smile as she prepares my order. Usually after a minute or two, her sister enters the room (sometimes her mother) and the conversation abruptly ends.  Could it be that Amish women are different?

I know this single woman’s father quite well. He did some logging on my place and is some kind of elder in the community; very easy to converse with.

As far as relationships; my neighbors keep that to themselves. What I do know is that a number of local Amish men and some women have left their former lives.
In the right circumstances, if a guy were able to befriend an Amish lady; she would have already made the decision to start down the path of leaving her family ending with some form of shunning. Who would ever want to deal with that?

The few Amish and Mennonite women I’ve had contact with certainly seem too have been raised differently.  Could an Amish or Mennonite woman who has been cloistered from birth in a completely different world be a viable alternative  (to the impossible modern day females) or are they all basically the same?

Women are women so this entire train of thought is essentially nothing more than an exercise in futility. Just some daydreaming.

“they’re all nawalt’s, until they’re not”

just like the prized asian women some guys talk about, going over seas for a perfect bride, then they bring them back to the west and all of a sudden shes the biggest bitch they ever knew. so yea i would say they’re all the same for the most part, if they arnt in that moment, wait until menopause…lol

“they’re all nawalt’s, until they’re not”

you’re exactly correct;

and some of them go through a crazy rebellious rite of passage “rumspringa” before joining back up so my daydreaming that maybe an Amish woman could somehow be totally different … deep down I know that it just couldn’t be

A similar issue is addressed in the excellent movie Witness with Harrison Ford.

“they’re all nawalt’s, until they’re not”

Best quote ever. Just 6 little words but it sums up every reason in the world why we are smart to be MGTOWs.